I don't like fish, my boyfriend does. This was so wonderful though!! I did not think I would like the sesame oil, I was not fond of the smell. But the end result was a flavorful, mild, delicious dinner I will surely make again.

Our family ate this but did not really enjoy it. Did not care for the flavor, followed recipe exactly as shown. Will not make again.

wonderfully moist fish. i followed the recipe but didn't measure things out exactly ... just kinda eyeballed it. it was very very good. have prepared this way several times now.

This was good except something about the Italian seasoning didn't jive for me and I'd probably replace that next time. My boyfriend really enjoyed however.

I added finely sliced mushrooms and sprinkled sesame seeds over the top. It was delicious.

Such great flavor and the fish were so moist. I used 3 small cloves of garlic and turned into a paste with a little salt. Then combined all the ingredients and brushed over the fish. They only got about 10 minutes of marinating time but turned out great anyway.

Perfect recipe for Tilapia! I marinated in ziplock bag, per other's suggestions. I ran out of sesame oil and only had just over 1/8 cup for 4 fillets - was totally fine and will make it the same way next time. Paired with Homemade Basil noodles and topped with wilted baby spinach and toasted almonds. My husband called it a "gourmet restaurant quality meal!" Thanks for the recipe!

One of my alltime favorite recipes, and so easy to make. If you use the very thin, previously frozen filets they get a bit crispy around the edges when baked.

This recipe was so simple! And it was absolutely delicious. Definitely a keeper!

This was tasty and easy to prepare, and my husband and I enjoyed it, so I'll definitely be making it again. I was a little wary of using Italian seasoning after reading some of the reviews, but we thought it was a nice blend of flavors. I do have a few suggestions, though: (1) 1/4 cup of oil for 2 4-oz fillets of tilapia is MUCH TOO MUCH oil! Using half that amount still provides you with enough flavor and gives you enough liquid to drizzle over the top after it's done cooking. (2) Just marinade the fish in the same (non-metal) dish you're going to cook it in - one less dish to clean and easier than pouring oil from one dish to another. (3) Definitely sprinkle some toasted sesame seeds on top of the fish - adds good texture and additional flavor. You can buy pre-roasted seeds in well-stocked grocery stores in the asian food aisle (look for it with the sushi making ingredients). (4) Try to use actual sesame oil and not just vegetable oil infused with sesame flavor - it's a much richer taste. Thanks for the recipe!

I don't care for fish, but I love the taste of sesame oil. This is a fish I will make again. I definitely enjoyed it.

so easy and fast to make. my 2 year old even loves this.

Thirty minutes is way too long for this fish--it came out crispy which is not what I was expecting for baked fish, and I only left it in for about 20-25 minutes! Plus, the marinade really didn't sink into the fish all that well, so the flavor was lackluster--bland, in spite of my adding some powdered ginger towards the end along with roasted sesame seeds. I might play again with this recipe but it won't be anytime soon. My husband suggested that next time I could add a little white wine for moisture, but he also thought thirty minutes would still be way too long for such a light fish.

This was really good. I followed the recipe precisely. A word of caution, I didn't have enough tilapia, so I decided to use some salmon as well. But the salmon didn't go well with this recipe. Stick with Tilapia. You won't regret it!

this was great. the family really loved this one. very quick and easy. will keep this as a regular!!!

I really enjoyed the flavor of this recipe. I think I might sprinkle some sesame seeds on top next time. For a nice presentation use black and white sesame seeds!

This dish is perfect as-is, & fortunately I was able to marinate the tilapia for several hours. Served with a side of steamed asparagus and, as a bed, a slightly simplified version of Red Chard and Caramelized Onions [from this site], the plates looked gorgeous & my family raved about the combination. Thanks so very much, Demi.